“Fireworks”, Robert Byers.

Christmas Dinner.
Resize JPEGS in Windows

Upcoming competitions information.

Using Windows Movie Maker for Audio-Visual

22 November. The poetry and picture contest revealed, as if we didn’t know, that we are better photographers than poets. Well done Elaine , Jean and Colin.

Roger Hegarty’s old family photos made me  (and probably many of us)  think of the shoeboxes full of images and negatives that sit in cupboards in most of our homes, unlabelled and increasingly unidentifiable with each passing generation;- the ones we’re really going to get around to sorting one of these years… Interesting to see the post-war appearance of synthetic  fibre materials, colour film, the disappearance of hats as cars  came in  etc. It would be interesting to get a lineal time sequence of a single  place , right from 1900 to today and do a timelapse movie. Wish I’d thought of it forty years ago. Bit late to begin now.

Thanks to those who brought gifts of biscuits and coffee- and especially the cherry liqueurs! (Those are addictive- but would you die of alcohol poisoning or cholesterol overdose first?).

15th November – After a few laptop related hiccups, Prof Gordon Findlater gave us an informed tale of Burke & Hare’s dark deeds back in the Auld Reekie of 1828-29. There was a lot here  that I had never heard- and I bet  my wife didn’t know the building she worked in for years was on the site of some of the grisly events.
I reckon the young lady Ph.D. student maybe was happier not knowing what was under that trapdoor!
Many thanks to Gordon for riding all the way  from Dunfermline on a suitably dark and  chilly night to inform and entertain us.
The Botanics pics in the latter part were as spaced out as a sixties drugs bust- and all done on a toasted marshmallow!

13th November:-Updated score sheet after the SPF event is on the Members’ page, in both Excel 97 and PDF format.. We did not fare well in this competition. In fact, we were last.

Link to SPF page with scores.

10th November:- Haddington beat North Berwick by a scant 8 points, largely thanks to images from Andy Bennetts and Ann Jeffray. Full updated scoresheet at bottom of Members’ Page. NB had some crackers. Good biscuits, too. Thanks for a good evening. The frostbite is getting better.


8th November was the First Exposure competition. Our thanks again to Neil Scott for his informative judging. If competitions are to have value as a tool for improving our photography, we must get feedback from a judge, not simply scores. Neil stressed  that we should learn not just from a judge’s comments about our own images, but about all the images.

His  description of images as “Record shots” doesn’t mean don’t take record shots- but once you have those saved, look for something different in addition. His point is that Camera Club Competition Photography (CCCP) is about a different genre of picture. What’s wanted in competitions is a degree of originality as well as the sort of technical quality required for a calendar, postcard or magazine picture.

CCCP is not the only kind of photography there is, or even the one you as a photographer may want to focus on most of the time. Do your thing. It pays to learn how to do it better and how to have more fun in doing so and feedback from competitions may help you do that.

Horses for courses. If your aim is to win competitions, give ’em what they want. If your aim is to learn, give ’em what you want and see what they think. Competitions are not the goal. They’re a tool.

Here’s a CCCP Red Squirrel. Subject sharp, a bit off centre, catchlight in the eye, bit of tree for context, background uncluttered and  a bit  out of focus (Gaussian Blur!). There’s just one problem. It’s a grey squirrel and I’d happily settle for a decent record shot of a proper red one . I’ll keep trying.


4 November.

So- did everyone else get lost in the woods too? Thursday 4th saw a mob of photographers wandering in the Botanics, trying to photograph lights that changed every couple of seconds. My favourite (and one of the few recognisable images) was the projection of plant hunter George Forrest.

2 November already. Malkit returned, bearing  lights and umbrellas. His main message was to give the camera lots of artificial light so you can forget about shutter speed and ISO and just use aperture to control exposure and depth of field. The problems start when you can’t find the sub-sub menu of the sub menu of the flash menu that stops your camera trying to expose  using the 2-candlepower trigger flash you never used before.

As so often, “Read The Friendly Manual” is good advice.

To judge by the results though, most folk got it right.  This was a lot of ground to cover with a big group and a few folk had to leave before the hands-on work got started. Maybe next time we should start with the practical bits and do the theory at the end?


25th October was a “putting the boot in on the other foot” evening, when Andy Bennetts explained how to become a judge and then gave us a shot at it. Unsurprisingly, we all did incredibly well, because, as we all suspected, it’s dead easy. So that’s that then. Next week, we learn how to be concert violinists.

On October 11th, Sandy Cleland gave us a  show of masterly wildlife images, mostly from Scotland and the wider UK, with some from abroad. Sandy makes it sound so easy. He just happens to be wandering along a road and a beast of some sort just stops what it was doing and poses alongside him.

Aye, right.

The clear, but modestly unspoken message of proper natural history photographers like Sandy Cleland or Laurie Campbell, is  that you actually need to know a great deal about the creatures you are observing, their habitat and ethology – and you have to wander along a great many roads, for many years, with infinite patience, respect for nature and a very precise vision of what you hope to find there – to capture images like these – not just of a bird on a twig  in the distance, but of an animal actively doing what it does best in its own environment.

The only problem with a demonstration of mastery  like this is that I don’t know whether to be inspired, or to sell the camera in despair. Lovely stuff.


So – 4th October was our first try at a problems and answers night. More problems than answers, maybe, but part of the idea was to find out what basic knowledge levels are like and to get folk talking to each other.  To judge by the noise levels, we managed that at least.

Next time we do this,  we want to be able to focus on what folk want to do, want to know. To that end, please give us feedback. What was right, what wrong, helpful, confusing etc. – what would you do if you organised it, what do you want to find out about? Let us know. Don’t be shy. It’s YOUR club. Send comments to . The more the better. We can sort them and look for common factors to use  as a preparation for next time.


Last Tuesday, 27th September we had our first encounter with Malkit Benning, (He’ll be back!), who gave us tips and practical experience of studio portrait photography. No White Rhinos or racehorses, but thanks to Louise for her patience as model.

A page of Malkit’s notes is available below as a 1997 DOC file or as plain text.

Downloadable Doc 97 file
Text file

On Tuesday 20th September,  we had a talk from Lindsay Robertson, which illustrated how uniquely personal photography can be, both as a recording medium and as an art form. Lindsay is an advocate of film over digital, quality over quantity,  and of doing things the way your heart tells you is right for you. Not many speakers show up with a van load of  large , framed prints which sell (when they sell!)  for four figures – or with such illustrative invisible slides. The fact he forgot the digital part of his presentation may be more than chance. The prints are unforgettable.

His point about a life in photography was that while it sometimes pays, it’s always worth doing, if you do the best you can.

His challenge to us as photographers- to take one, single image and get it right, is very much at odds with current notions of taking 10 frames per second and hoping one comes out right- to say nothing of shooting 4k video and extracting still frames, a technology eagerly anticipated by many.

Not everyone can maintain this sort of personal discipline, nor should they. Photography  is a hobby, too. There are many facets to photography and Lindsay’s way is personal and distinctive to himself- a timely reminder at the start of the season that camera club competition photography is far from the only game in town and doing what you choose to do is rather the point.


We kicked off  the 16_17 season on Tuesday 13th September with a talk from new president Susan Kempson outlining her plan for the Autumn and Winter syllabus. It was good to see a number of new faces  and we hope to see you all back next week.

PLEASE REMEMBER YOUR MEMBERSHIP BADGE ______________________________________________________________________________

 The president’s Summer newsletter is here:- Summer Newsletter 2016



Top of Page